Is a metal roof really the best choice in hail country? Metal roofing is durable, but it may not always be the best option for homeowners in the hail-prone Black Hills! While some hail dents are considered cosmetic, hail damage to the seams or connections of a metal roof can compromise its ability to keep water out, making it more than just a cosmetic concern. For this project, the homeowners switched from metal roofing to Malarkey Highlander asphalt shingles. Malarkey Highlander shingles offer Class 3 impact resistance, helping protect homes against hail while providing a beautiful, traditional look. At Weather-Tite Exteriors, we're educators first. We help homeowners understand their roofing options so they can make the best decision for their home.